Fixing a Running Toilet: Flapper, Fill Valve and Chain

Hearing your toilet refill on its own is wasteful and hard to ignore. If you want to know how to fix a running toilet, check the flapper first, then the chain and the fill valve. This guide sits within our…

how to fix a running toilet

Hearing your toilet refill on its own is wasteful and hard to ignore. If you want to know how to fix a running toilet, check the flapper first, then the chain and the fill valve.

This guide sits within our collection of diy home repairs, which covers other simple jobs around the house.

Item Value
Water-off leak test wait At least 25 minutes
Flapper chain slack 1 to 2 chain links
Tank water level target 1/2- to one-inch below the top of the overflow pipe
Fill valve locknut A half turn past hand tight

These figures come from Korky’s running toilet guide and Family Handyman’s repair guide. They can change, so check the source before you rely on them.

Why does a toilet keep running?

A toilet runs when water escapes from the tank or when the fill valve never shuts off. According to Korky, in most cases a worn flapper or flush valve seal lets water slowly leak from the tank into the bowl. As the tank level drops, the fill valve float drops with it and turns the water back on.

The causes listed by Bob Vila are usually one of these:

  • A worn, bent or warped flapper.
  • A flapper chain that is twisted or the wrong length.
  • A water level set too high, so water spills into the overflow tube.
  • A broken or stuck float, or a failing fill valve.
  • An overflow tube that is damaged or too short.

The same guide adds that a constantly running toilet may wear out sooner because of the extra work its parts do, on top of a higher water bill.

Test first to find the leaking part

Guessing means buying parts you may not need. A short test tells you whether the leak is at the flapper or somewhere else.

  1. Flush the toilet and let the tank refill.
  2. Mark the water level on the inside of the tank with a pencil.
  3. Turn off the water supply valve and leave the toilet alone.
  4. Check whether the water has dropped below your pencil mark.

Korky says to wait for at least 25 minutes. If the level falls to the flapper or flush seal, the flapper or seal needs replacing; if it falls to the overflow tube or the bottom of the tank, the flush valve needs replacing.

There is also a quicker check. Family Handyman suggests pressing down on the flapper with a stick while the toilet is running: if the noise stops, the flapper is not sealing.

If the flapper seals well but the sound continues, watch the tank refill. Water that keeps running after the tank is full points to a stuck float or a faulty fill valve, as Korky explains.

Replace the flapper and set the chain

You usually do not need to take apart the whole toilet for this. Bob Vila notes that if the flapper or chain is the cause, you can replace just that part without removing the entire flush valve assembly.

  1. Shut off the water supply valve under the toilet, then flush to drain most of the tank.
  2. Unhook the old flapper and take it with you to match the type.
  3. Install the new flapper following the instructions on its package.
  4. Hook the chain onto the flush lever arm so there is a little slack when the flapper is closed.
  5. Turn the water back on and watch that the flapper closes fully.

Family Handyman adds a safety note: if the toilet’s own shutoff valve leaks, use the main shutoff valve instead.

Chain length matters more than it looks. Korky recommends leaving only 1 to 2 chain links of slack, so spare links cannot fall into the drain opening and the flapper is not held open by a tight chain. A twisted chain can cause the same leak, according to Bob Vila.

A miniature toilet and a plumber figurine stand against a green tiled background.

Adjust or replace the fill valve

If water flows into the overflow tube, the level may simply be set too high. Bob Vila describes turning the float adjustment screw about a quarter-turn counterclockwise with a screwdriver or pliers, repeating until water no longer reaches the overflow tube.

On a float-arm style valve, Family Handyman says to bend or adjust the arm so filling stops when the water is 1/2- to one-inch below the top of the overflow pipe. It also suggests lifting the arm while the tank fills: if the water stops, the float arm setting is the issue.

If adjusting does not help, replace the valve. The steps below follow Family Handyman, which says to tighten the new locknut a half turn past hand tight.

  1. Turn off the water supply, flush and sponge out what is left in the tank.
  2. Disconnect the supply line, unscrew the locknut and lift out the old fill valve.
  3. Insert the new valve following its instruction sheet and tighten the locknut.
  4. Attach the fill tube to the valve and the angle adapter, shortening it if it kinks.
  5. Clip the adapter onto the overflow pipe, turn on the water and test-flush.

Still running after the repair?

A new flapper does not always end the problem. Korky lists several things to recheck:

  • The flapper must match the size of the flush valve opening.
  • Tower or canister valves need a seal made for that specific model.
  • Debris or mineral deposits on the sealing surface should be cleaned off.
  • Cracks or warping in the flush valve mean the valve needs replacing.

Replacing the flush valve is a bigger job than a flapper swap. Bob Vila describes removing the tank-to-bowl bolts and lifting the tank off the base; if that sounds beyond your comfort level, a licensed plumber is a sensible call.

While you are in the bathroom, you may want to read about how to unclog a drain for slow sinks and tubs. Sealing gaps around the tub is covered in our guide on how to caulk a bathtub.

Frequently asked questions

Why does my toilet refill by itself when nobody has used it?

Show answer

A slow leak past the flapper lowers the tank level, which makes the fill valve top it up. The pencil-mark test above confirms it without any parts.

Can I fix it without buying anything?

Show answer

Sometimes. Adjusting the chain, lowering the float or cleaning mineral buildup from the drain opening, as Korky describes, can be enough.

How do I tell a flapper problem from a fill valve problem?

Show answer

If pushing the flapper down quiets the toilet, the flapper is at fault. If the tank is full and water keeps coming in, look at the float and fill valve instead.

Do I need to shut off the water first?

Show answer

For any work on the flapper, fill valve or flush valve, yes. Close the supply valve before you start, as Family Handyman advises for flapper replacement.

❧